|
|
Written by: Jason
Dollar
As the role of information technology (IT) becomes more and more
vital in today’s workplace, businesses are relying heavily
on those who are trained and equipped to stay up to date with new
changes. For this major reason, many of today’s Financial
Institutions and more importantly community banks have chosen to
outsource their IT services. Many do so because they lack the human
capital to provide quality in-house IT functions, and others do
so because they lack the financial capital needed to pay these individuals.
It seems as though it is a win-win relationship for the Bank and
the IT firm, but while this practice is becoming more commonly accepted
in today’s banking environment, it should be noted that it
does not come without certain risks associated with all forms of
outsourcing.
Financial Institutions are not the only entities who are looking
to outsource much of their Information Technology Services. According
to a report from INPUT, it is estimated that the U.S. Government
outsourcing is scheduled to grow by 55% by the year 2009. If this
is true, outsourcing will be one of the fastest-growing segments
of the federal IT budget over the next few years. According to Chris
Campbell, a Senior Analyst of Federal Market Analysis, “An
organization will be most effective when it focuses on things that
it does best. In other words, the Department of Defense is best
at fighting military actions, not administering data centers. The
Federal Bureau of Investigation is best at investigating crimes,
not developing software.” As for Banks, the same rational
is held true. Many banks feel that their time is better spent focusing
on lending and interest rate risk analysis rather than concerning
themselves with an area such as information technology that is foreign
to most. This explains why roughly 75% of bank’s outsourcing
costs are related to information technology, while the other 25%
is comprised of outsourcing in the areas of check processing, mortgage
processing, and credit card processing. Going along with this pattern,
we find that IT outsourcing is not only a North American phenomenon.
According to a report by OutsourcingFinancialServices.com, of the
Total Contract Value of all outsourcing done by financial institutions
during the time period from 1999-2004, North America accounted for
only 36% of the $90.5 billion. Europe, the Middle East, and Africa
accounted for 35%, Asia/Pacific for 13%, and other multi-regional
regions accounting for the other 16%.
Although outsourcing has become the norm rather than the exception
for community banks, there are certain factors and risks that should
be considered when deciding whether or not to outsource and who
to use. According to the Federal Financial Institutions Examination
Council (FFIEC) Information Technology Examination Handbook, management
may choose to outsource its operations for any of the following
reasons:
Gain operational or financial efficiencies
Increase management focus on core business functions
Refocus limited internal resources on core functions
Obtain specialized expertise
Increase availability of services
Accelerate delivery of products or services through new delivery
channels
Increase ability to acquire and support current technology and avoid
obsolescence
Conserve capital for other business ventures
According to the FFIEC, “Outsourcing of technology-related
services may improve quality, reduce costs, strengthen controls,
and achieve the objectives listed previously. Ultimately, the decision
to outsource should fit into the institution’s overall strategic
plan and objectives.”
Along with the decision to outsource, the FFIEC notes that the
financial institution should conduct a risk assessment. Understood
in the risk assessment is the fact that “the Board of Directors
and Senior Management are responsible for understanding the risks
associated with outsourcing arrangements for technology services
and ensuring that effective risk management practices are in place.
In addition, the nature of the service provided, such as bill payment,
funds transfer, or emerging electronic services, may result in entities
performing transactions on behalf of the institution, such as collection
or disbursement of funds, that can increase the levels of credit,
liquidity, transactions, and reputation risks.”
The FFIEC points out that an outsourcing risk assessment should
consider the following:
Strategic goals, objectives, and business needs of the financial
institution
Ability to evaluate and oversee outsourcing relationships
Importance and criticality of the services to the financial institution
Defined requirement for the outsourced activity
Necessary controls and reporting processes
Contractual obligations and requirements for the service provider
Contingency plans, including availability of alternative service
providers, costs and resources required to switch service providers.
Ongoing assessment of outsourcing arrangement to evaluate consistency
with strategic objectives and service provider performance
Regulatory requirements and guidance for the business lines affected
and technologies used.
It is critical that financial institutions consider all of these
factors and all of its risks when choosing an outsourcing firm,
because for banks, the information that it outsourced not only affects
the bank, but also all of its customer’s personal information.
A good idea may be to obtain a SAS 70 report on your potential vendor.
This report will help you analyze the strength of the business and
its ability to support your needs as an organization. The need to
be thorough has never been more evident than with the current stringent
IT exams being conducted throughout the Community Bank Sector.
Related Articles
Contact Nichols,
Cauley & Associates by Email,
phone, or online
form with your questions.
Site visitors should keep in mind
that the content is generally designed to be of general applicability.
Particular state laws, regulations and special contractual provisions
can greatly impact rights, responsibilities and legal obligations.
Only a competent attorney, accountant or other professional looking
at all the pertinent facts and circumstances of a particular situation
can provide definitive guidance for you. Please refer to our important
legal discalimer which can be accessed from the bottom of any BankAudit.net
webpage.
|
 |
 |
 |